Commentary

Why Small Businesses Fail at Social Media

November 20, 2009 | by SMC of SLC

by Scott Cowley, SMC of SLC member

091119 SM Business fail whale

Social media for small business is awesome! It can quickly level the playing field with publicity, promotion, and market engagement at a fraction of the cost of traditional marketing channels. I’m convinced that any small business that engages consumers with blogging, Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube (among other platforms) will always win the battle for mindshare and market share over those that rely on traditional marketing alone.

What you often read about are the “Cinderella stories” of small companies that went from the bottom of the barrel to top dog using social media. What you don’t see are the countless times that social media fails in the small business arena. By fails, I mean that the business stops doing it or continues doing it with no real results. Often, this failure leads small business owners to become disillusioned with social media, which can put them farther behind the curve. And it’s such a shame, because social media has the greatest potential for small businesses.

So why does social media fail so frequently for small businesses? In my experience, here are some of the biggest reasons:

Failure to act. Social media may be free, but it takes time and many small businesses jump into it without recognizing the commitment or becoming familiar with the platforms first. There’s a definite learning curve and a consistent time investment required for writing blog posts, Facebook posts, Twitter posts, creating YouTube videos, etc. A business can’t just stick its foot in the social media game once a month and expect to be effective. Many treat it that way.

Failure to view social media as more than an advertising channel. There’s a time and a place for everything, including self-promotion, but too many company blogs, Facebook pages and Twitter streams are populated completely with advertising. That’s not social. That’s selfish. Even businesses should try to follow the “90-10 rule.”

Failure to target. Businesses may engage people with social media, but engage them in the wrong conversations. If you talk to anyone about anything and everything, you’re treating social media like a chat room. Social media should be tied to relevant business and conversation goals. Adding your voice to industry discussions establishes a business’s credibility. Helping individuals meet their own life goals and objectives through your products and services, and especially your expertise, helps both of you.

Failure to humanize the brand. Many companies act and engage as though the company is the human. This is the old media approach. Small businesses that are most effective at meeting business objectives with social media aren’t afraid to introduce people to the business and the people behind the business. When customers are friends with your employees, they’ll be repeat customers and advocates (which underscores the importance of hiring the right people).

Social media isn’t ideal for every small business, but it can work for many. It needs to be consistent, helpful, engaging, relevant to the business, and human to the public for it to succeed. Small businesses that learn how to do these things now can expect to be big businesses down the road.

About the Author: Scott Cowley does search engine optimization and social media for SEO.com and is passionate about helping clients catch the vision of how social media can be put to use. He enjoys making friends through SMCSLC and SMCUV and currently resides in Provo with his wife Kathy.

6 Comments For This Post

  1. Sheri Bell-Rehwoldt

    Nice article, Scott. Thanks for contributing! ;-)

  2. Jack Hadley

    Nicely written Scott. And true.

    One other thing I would add is that many small businesses fail to address the disconnect between their existing, traditional marketing efforts and their “new marketing” efforts. A well-developed strategy must be integrated.

    If, for example, social media tools are successfully employed, but eyes and interest are driven to a poor website, the efforts to drive people there does little good. This is very common among small businesses.

    I believe that social media marketing gives small businesses an opportunity to rethink everything about their marketing and to be sure every touch is consistent and thoughtful.

    Social media marketing is not the small business silver bullet that makes up for everything else that’s mediocre.

  3. Arizona Social Media PR Agency

    I usually dont post in Blogs but your blog forced me to, amazing work.. beautiful

  4. Attili Sattibabu

    Good post mate!! Keep ‘em flowing!

  5. chat rooms the

    I dont usually reply to posts but in this case. WoW!

  6. Aisha Achekian

    Thanks for the article that you have. I came across a new one the other day. They look open for business, but very similar to linkedin.com with more of a social business directory look and feel. Nice clean interface though. Found it at SocialTerrain.com

4 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Why Small Businesses Fail at Social Media | SEO Partners

    [...] See original here: Why Small Businesses Fail at Social Media [...]

  2. Tweets that mention Why Small Businesses Fail at Social Media | SMC of SLC -- Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by SMC of SLC, Sheri Bell-Rehwoldt. Sheri Bell-Rehwoldt said: Why small businesses fail at social media: #SMCSLC post from member @scottcowley http://urlzen.com/10z1 (via @SMCSLC) [...]

  3. Tweets that mention Why Small Businesses Fail at Social Media | SMC of SLC -- Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Gus Svendsen, Josh Shua Peters. Josh Shua Peters said: Why Small Businesses Fail at Social Media http://go.shuaism.com/q55e [...]

  4. uberVU - social comments

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by BELLREHWOLDT: Why small businesses fail at social media: #SMCSLC post from member @scottcowley http://urlzen.com/10z1 (via @SMCSLC)…

Leave a Reply

About SMC of SLC

Social Media Club of Salt Lake City (SMC of SLC) supports the central focus of the worldwide organization, which is headquartered in San Francisco, California.

The organization’s four focus areas are:

  • Expand media literacy
  • Share lessons learned among practitioners
  • Encourage adoption of industry standards
  • Promote ethical practices through discussion and actions

The goal of SMC of SLC is to provide a local forum and networking opportunity for social media practitioners, or those interested in learning more.

Membership Directory

Sign-up to be included in our electronic membership directory. Include your contact information and find information for reaching out to fellow SMC of SLC members and friends.

Social Media Minute on Utah Pulse

The Social Media Club of Salt Lake City is pleased to partner with a local new media publication – in other words, not a traditional newspaper – the Utah Pulse.

Members of the SMC of SLC leadership team and other members will contribute to Utah Pulse on a weekly basis in the Social Media Minute.

The Social Media Minute is published each Friday and includes tips and tools on how to use new media.

Read the Social Media Minute at UtahPulse.com.